Guides

Which magnesium should I take?

By the Nirga team · Updated

In short

For daily use, pick a form that is well absorbed and easy on the gut: bisglycinate first, citrate if your digestion handles it. Avoid oxide, which is poorly absorbed. Always check the amount of elemental magnesium per serving.

Watch the video · 0:45Which magnesium to choose, in under a minuteWhich form suits which need, the daily upper limit from supplements and what to check on the label.With voice-over

The three criteria

  1. Absorption. Soluble forms (citrate, bisglycinate, malate) are absorbed better than poorly soluble ones (oxide).
  2. Digestive tolerance. Unabsorbed magnesium draws water into the gut. The less a form is absorbed, the more laxative it is.
  3. Elemental magnesium. This is the number to compare between products, against the price per day.

Type by type

Bisglycinate. Magnesium bound to two glycine molecules. Well absorbed and very well tolerated. The safest pick for daily use. Its drawback: you often need two or three capsules to reach a full serving.

Citrate. Well absorbed and cheaper. It becomes laxative as the dose rises, which also makes it a common choice for constipation.

Oxide. A lot of magnesium per capsule, but only a small share is absorbed. The cheapest form and the one that causes the most digestive upset. More in magnesium oxide.

Malate and taurate. Well tolerated. Few studies compare them directly with other forms. See malate and taurate.

L-threonate. Marketed for memory and focus. Each serving provides little magnesium and human evidence is limited.

Liposomal. A delivery technology rather than a form. See liposomal magnesium.

Our recommendation by situation

Your situation Preferred form
Daily use, nothing special Bisglycinate
Sensitive stomach Bisglycinate
Tendency to constipation Citrate
Tight budget Citrate
Evening use Bisglycinate

For a detailed look at the two most searched forms, read bisglycinate vs citrate. For daily needs and precautions, see the complete magnesium guide.

How to read a magnesium label

The big number on the front is usually the weight of the compound, not of the magnesium. What counts is the line “magnesium” or “elemental magnesium”.

A worked example: a capsule of 500 mg of magnesium bisglycinate contains about 10 to 14% magnesium, so roughly 50 to 70 mg. To reach 200 mg of magnesium you need three or four capsules. A 500 mg capsule of magnesium oxide contains about 300 mg of magnesium, but only a small part of it is absorbed.

Three questions to ask of any product:

  1. How many milligrams of elemental magnesium per serving?
  2. How many capsules make one serving?
  3. What does one day cost at that serving?

How much magnesium do you need?

Group Recommended daily intake
Men 19 to 30 400 mg
Men 31 and over 420 mg
Women 19 to 30 310 mg
Women 31 and over 320 mg
Pregnancy 350 to 360 mg

These figures cover everything you eat and drink. A supplement fills the gap; it does not have to provide the whole amount. From supplements alone, adults should stay under 350 mg a day.

Which magnesium for which goal?

For sleep

No form has been shown to beat the others for sleep. Bisglycinate is the usual choice because it is taken in the evening without upsetting the gut. Details in magnesium and sleep.

For stress and tiredness

Magnesium contributes to normal psychological function and to reducing fatigue whatever the form. Choose one you tolerate well enough to take every day: bisglycinate or malate.

For cramps and sport

Trials have not shown a clear effect on cramps. If your intake is low, a well-absorbed form is still worth taking. See magnesium for athletes.

For constipation

Citrate or oxide, precisely because they are laxative. This is occasional use, not a daily routine.

For women

Needs change with pregnancy and age. See magnesium for women.

Capsules, powder, liquid or gummies?

  • Capsules: the most practical, with a precise dose.
  • Powder: cheaper per dose and easy to adjust, but the taste is not for everyone.
  • Liquid: useful if you cannot swallow capsules. Check the dose per spoon. More in liquid magnesium.
  • Gummies: pleasant, but they hold little magnesium each and often contain sugar or sweeteners.

What we would avoid

  • Labels that give the weight of the compound and hide the elemental magnesium.
  • “Proprietary blends” of several forms with no amount for each.
  • Servings that exceed 350 mg of magnesium a day.
  • Promises of an effect in a few days.

Magnesium with other supplements and medicines

Very high doses of zinc can reduce magnesium absorption, so take them at different times. Magnesium itself reduces the absorption of some antibiotics, thyroid medication and osteoporosis drugs: leave at least two hours. With kidney disease, do not take magnesium without medical advice.

The choice in thirty seconds

  • You want one magnesium for every day and your gut is easily upset: bisglycinate.
  • You want the best price and tolerate it: citrate.
  • You are often constipated: citrate, or oxide occasionally.
  • You prefer to take it in the morning: malate.
  • You cannot swallow capsules: a liquid or a powder.
  • You have kidney disease or take regular medication: ask your doctor first, whatever the form.

How to compare the price per day

The price of a box says nothing. What you pay for is elemental magnesium.

  1. Find the elemental magnesium per capsule on the label.
  2. Divide your daily target by that number to get the capsules per day.
  3. Divide the capsules in the box by the capsules per day: that is how many days the box lasts.
  4. Divide the price by the number of days.

An example with round numbers: a box of 90 capsules at 60 mg of magnesium each lasts 30 days at 180 mg a day. A box of 60 capsules at 100 mg each lasts 30 days at 200 mg a day. The second box holds fewer capsules and covers the same month.

Glycinate or bisglycinate: the same thing?

In practice, yes. “Bisglycinate” says that each magnesium atom is bound to two glycine molecules, which is the usual structure. “Glycinate” is the shorter name for the same compound. What matters more is whether it is fully chelated or “buffered” with oxide, and the ingredient list tells you.

Two forms worth a closer look

L-threonate. Developed and patented for its ability to raise magnesium in the brain in animal studies. Human trials on memory are few and small. It contains about 8% magnesium, so a serving covers only a small part of daily needs. It is the most expensive form per milligram.

Chloride. Dissolves very well and is well absorbed. Its bitter, salty taste limits it to liquids and some tablets, and it can irritate a sensitive stomach.

Needs by age

Age Men Women
14 to 18 410 mg 360 mg
19 to 30 400 mg 310 mg
31 to 50 420 mg 320 mg
51 and over 420 mg 320 mg

Needs do not rise after 50, but absorption falls and the kidneys clear less. Older adults are the group most likely to be low in magnesium and also the group that should check kidney function before supplementing.

Signs that your current form does not suit you

What you notice What to try
Loose stools Lower the dose, split it in two, or move from citrate or oxide to bisglycinate
Nausea on an empty stomach Take it with a meal
Too many capsules a day A form with more magnesium per capsule, or a powder
No effect after a month Check the elemental dose first; your intake may not have been low

Ten checks before you buy

  1. Elemental magnesium per serving is stated.
  2. The form is named in full.
  3. No “proprietary blend”.
  4. Serving size and capsules per serving are clear.
  5. The daily serving stays under 350 mg of magnesium.
  6. The other ingredients are few and listed.
  7. A batch number and an expiry date are printed.
  8. A lab report is available.
  9. Kosher certification, if you need it, names the certifying body.
  10. The manufacturer is identified and reachable.

What a clear label looks like

Magnesium bisglycinate, fully chelated. Per 2 capsules: 200 mg of elemental magnesium. Other ingredients: plant capsule. Batch number, expiry date, certifying body.

If a label cannot be summed up this simply, be cautious.

Glossary

  • Elemental magnesium: the weight of magnesium itself, without its partner.
  • Chelate: magnesium bound to amino acids.
  • Buffered: a chelate blended with magnesium oxide.
  • Bioavailability: the share of a dose that reaches the bloodstream.
  • Upper limit: the highest daily amount from supplements considered safe, 350 mg for adults.

To see what the brands on Israeli shelves actually state on their labels, form by form, read our comparison of magnesium brands in Israel.

What we chose

Our magnesium bisglycinate will come in capsules, made in Israel and kosher.

For every form side by side, see types of magnesium. Training hard? Read magnesium for athletes.

Frequently asked questions

Which magnesium is best for a sensitive stomach?

Bisglycinate. Citrate, and especially oxide, cause loose stools more often.

Is marine magnesium better?

No. It is mostly magnesium oxide and hydroxide extracted from seawater, both poorly absorbed.

Is liposomal magnesium worth the price?

It is marketed for better absorption, but independent comparisons with bisglycinate or citrate are lacking. It costs much more.

How much elemental magnesium is in a bisglycinate capsule?

About 10 to 14% of the weight of the compound. A 500 mg capsule of magnesium bisglycinate provides roughly 50 to 70 mg of magnesium. Always check the label.

Which magnesium is best for sleep?

No form has been shown to be better than the others for sleep. Bisglycinate is the usual choice because it is well tolerated in the evening.

Can I take magnesium every day?

Yes. It is a nutrient the body needs daily. From supplements, adults should stay under 350 mg a day, and people with kidney disease need medical advice first.

Are magnesium glycinate and bisglycinate the same?

In practice, yes. Bisglycinate specifies that the magnesium is bound to two glycine molecules; glycinate is the shorter name for the same compound.

Is magnesium L-threonate worth it?

It was developed to raise magnesium in the brain in animal studies. Human trials are few and small, it provides little magnesium per serving and it is the most expensive form.

How do I compare the price of two magnesium supplements?

Compare the price per day at the same amount of elemental magnesium, not the price per box or per capsule.

Sources

Join the waitlist

This product launches soon. Leave your email and get 10% off on launch day.

By signing up you agree to receive our launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Join the waitlist

This product launches soon. Leave your email and get 10% off on launch day.

By signing up you agree to receive our launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.