Guides

Which collagen should you choose?

By the Nirga team · Updated

In short

No collagen has been shown to work better than another. Choose by use and by label: hydrolysed type I (marine or bovine) for skin, type II for joints, at least 2.5 g per daily serving, a kosher certificate if you need one, and the price per day.

The choice in thirty seconds

Your situation What to look for
Skin Hydrolysed type I, marine or bovine, 2.5 to 10 g a day
Knee or joint discomfort Hydrolysed collagen around 10 g a day, or type II
You keep kosher A recognised kosher certificate on the pack
You avoid beef Marine collagen
Fish allergy Bovine collagen
Tight budget Unflavoured bovine powder

Five things to read on the label

  1. The word hydrolysed (or peptides). It is the form used in trials.
  2. The source: bovine, marine, chicken. A label that hides it is a bad sign.
  3. The grams of collagen per serving, not the weight of the scoop with flavouring and sweetener.
  4. The type (I, II, III) when the product claims a specific use.
  5. Added ingredients: vitamin C is useful for collagen synthesis; long lists of plant extracts in tiny doses mostly add to the price.

Marine or bovine

Both give mostly type I collagen. No head-to-head trial shows one to be better. Marine collagen costs more and matters mainly to people who do not eat beef. People allergic to fish should avoid it.

Kosher collagen

Kashrut depends on the animal, the slaughter and the processing. Marine collagen from kosher fish and bovine collagen from kosher-slaughtered cattle can both be certified. In Israel, check for a recognised hechsher printed on the pack rather than a general statement.

Price per day

Divide the price by the number of days the pack lasts at the dose you take. A tub that looks cheap can cost more per day if a serving holds only 2 g.

What to expect

The evidence for skin is disputed and the evidence for joints is limited; details are in the collagen guide. Give a product the 8 to 12 weeks used in trials, then judge. For a supplement with stronger evidence in its own field, see our guide to creatine.

Frequently asked questions

Which collagen is most recommended?

None has proven superior. Pick a hydrolysed collagen that states its source, its type and the grams per serving, with at least 2.5 g a day.

Is marine collagen better than bovine?

No trial shows that. Both provide mostly type I. Marine suits people who avoid beef; bovine is usually cheaper.

Powder or capsules?

Powder. A 5 to 10 g serving would take five to ten capsules.

How long before judging the result?

Trials ran 8 to 12 weeks for skin and three to six months for joints. If nothing has changed by then, stopping is reasonable.

Sources

Join the waitlist

This product launches soon. Leave your email and get 10% off on launch day.

By signing up you agree to receive our launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Join the waitlist

This product launches soon. Leave your email and get 10% off on launch day.

By signing up you agree to receive our launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.