Comparisons

Magnesium bisglycinate vs citrate

By the Nirga team · Updated

In short

Both forms are well absorbed. Bisglycinate is gentler on the gut and suits daily use, especially in the evening. Citrate is cheaper and becomes laxative at higher doses, which helps if you tend to be constipated.

Watch the video · 0:42Bisglycinate or citrate, in under a minuteHow the two forms differ, the daily upper limit and how to choose between them.With voice-over

Comparison table

Bisglycinate Citrate Oxide
Composition Magnesium bound to glycine Magnesium bound to citric acid Magnesium bound to oxygen
Absorption Good Good Low
Digestive tolerance Very good Laxative at high doses Often laxative
Magnesium per capsule Lower Medium High
Price Higher Medium Low
Typical use Daily, evening General, constipation Tight budget

Choose bisglycinate if

  • you have a sensitive stomach;
  • you plan to take magnesium every day for several months;
  • you take it in the evening.

Choose citrate if

  • you tend to be constipated;
  • price is your first criterion;
  • you prefer a powder to dissolve.

What to check on the label

Compare the amount of elemental magnesium per daily serving, then divide the price of the bottle by the number of days it lasts. Two products at the same price can differ twofold in price per day.

For other forms (malate, taurate, threonate), read which magnesium to take. For daily needs and precautions, see the complete guide.

We chose bisglycinate.

The numbers side by side

Bisglycinate Citrate
Bound to Glycine, an amino acid Citric acid
Elemental magnesium About 10 to 14% About 16%
Magnesium in a 500 mg capsule About 50 to 70 mg About 80 mg
Capsules for 200 mg of magnesium Three to four Two to three
Laxative effect Rare Common at high doses
Sold as Mostly capsules Capsules, powder, liquid

Which one for which goal?

  • Sleep and evening use: bisglycinate, because it does not disturb the gut at night.
  • Constipation: citrate, precisely for its laxative effect.
  • Sport: either. Avoid trying citrate for the first time before a session.
  • Pregnancy: only with the agreement of the doctor or midwife, whatever the form.
  • Tight budget: citrate, especially as a powder.

Can you switch from one to the other?

Yes, from one day to the next. Keep the same amount of elemental magnesium, not the same number of capsules. If you move from citrate to bisglycinate because of loose stools, expect things to settle within a few days.

Three mistakes when comparing

  1. Comparing the price per box instead of the price per day at the same amount of magnesium.
  2. Reading “magnesium glycinate 1,000 mg” as 1,000 mg of magnesium.
  3. Choosing a “buffered” bisglycinate without noticing it is partly oxide. The ingredient list tells you.

To see what the brands on Israeli shelves actually state on their labels, form by form, read our comparison of magnesium brands in Israel.

Our verdict

For a daily supplement taken in the evening, bisglycinate is the more comfortable choice, which is why it is the form of our product. Citrate remains a very good option at a lower price for those who tolerate it. The other forms are compared in types of magnesium.

Frequently asked questions

Are bisglycinate and glycinate the same thing?

Yes. Both names describe magnesium bound to glycine. Bisglycinate specifies that there are two glycine molecules per magnesium atom.

Can I combine the two?

Yes, provided the total stays under 350 mg of magnesium a day from supplements.

What about magnesium oxide?

It holds a lot of magnesium per capsule but is poorly absorbed and often laxative. It is the cheapest form.

Which is better absorbed, magnesium bisglycinate or citrate?

Both are well absorbed. The practical difference is tolerance: citrate becomes laxative as the dose rises, bisglycinate rarely does.

What is buffered magnesium bisglycinate?

A bisglycinate mixed with magnesium oxide to raise the magnesium content per capsule. The ingredient list mentions oxide. It is less gentle than a fully chelated bisglycinate.

Sources

Join the waitlist

This product launches soon. Leave your email and get 10% off on launch day.

By signing up you agree to receive our launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Join the waitlist

This product launches soon. Leave your email and get 10% off on launch day.

By signing up you agree to receive our launch updates. You can unsubscribe at any time.